Cherry Picked

Guides / Hotel

The Sydney Hotel

This hotel has been hand-picked by the StayBoutique team and verified as an authentic boutique hotel

Vibe

Historic Elegance

Location

22 Winter Street, Edgartown, MA 02539

Formerly a magnificent Victorian home built in 1892 by Captain Charles W. Fisher, The Sydney was renovated and refreshed in 2015 and expanded in 2018. This chic jewel, located in the heart of Edgartown, includes the renowned l’etoile restaurant and features 8 stylish accommodations in the original Captain’s House and 14 guest rooms in the island’s newest hotel building. The Sydney is your key to an exclusive and relaxing Martha’s Vineyard vacation in the heart of downtown Edgartown. Step outside our front door and you are on Water Street, one of the village’s most sought after addresses. Specialty shops, galleries and gourmet restaurants line the street. The famous Edgartown Harbor is one block away.

Features & Amenities

  • Complimentary light breakfast
  • Flat screen TVs
  • Complimentary high-speed WiFi throughout property
  • Plush bathrobes
  • Super-soft linens
  • In-room safes
  • Individually controlled A/C and heat
  • Beach towels and chairs for Martha’s Vineyard beach excursions
  • Historic Captain’s House shares space with famed l’etoile restaurant and bar—book your reservation in advance!

​​The Best New Restaurants in London

London is eating well. A new wave of restaurants has arrived in the capital, and what unites the best of…

By StayBoutique Editors

Inside Puyu’s Vision for a New Kind of China Travel

Image Credit: Puyu Retreat Rachel Xia and Rania Zheng are rewriting what it means to experience one of the world’s…

By StayBoutique Editors

Jay Jeffers on Collected Living, Soulful Spaces, and the Art of the Boutique Stay

Image Credit: The Madrona Hotel The designer behind some of San Francisco’s most considered interiors never intended to own a…

By StayBoutique Editors

Baccarat Turns the Brera District into a Galactic Cathedral

Image Credit: Baccarat For Milan Design Week 2026, the French crystal Maison conjures a science fiction universe in the heart…

By StayBoutique Editors

​​The New London Boutique Hotels

London is having a moment. A new wave of boutique hotels has arrived in the capital, and they share a…

By StayBoutique Editors